Thursday, December 04, 2008

Why not 'sab chalta' hai

The recent horror that Mumbai and entire country saw unfolding on relentlessly insensitive media has left everyone shocked, dismayed, angry and what not. I knew media was going to abuse the ‘Mumbai Spirit’ term again without realizing there were people who had to move on with their lives. As I watched victims, who were holed up in Taj and Oberoi, I saw two different patterns emerging. People who were either too numb or ‘chalta hai’ types. One guy, hardly nineteen-twenty, who was there at one of the hotels at a wedding party as a videographer was back in business next day, all cheerful and smiling, since he had already had bookings in advance. Another guy, slightly older but still very young around twenty five, apparently from upper middle class was very emotional and furious in the TV interview. He complained that he was not able to sleep properly and he could not shake his mind of these attacks even for a minute. What set my mind thinking was whether people who fight everyday for their survival are better equipped to deal with this crisis, or they simply let their wounds fester in the cloak of life’s compulsion which everyone calls ‘spirit’. Whether these festering wounds become breeding ground for communal violence and hatred that we often get to see running amok on our streets or it’s just that people who generally think they are safe and secured, when come across such mishap get scarred more easily. 

3 comments:

  1. Sorry, but strongly object to a couple of points in ur post.
    a) the media infact did an extremely good job of covering the entire crisis. And I guess similar to how the 'mumbai spirit' was overplayed in the previous incidents, this time bashing those who overplayed it previously became the favourite sport
    b) the other guy who, according to you, was numb, was back at his job cos he had to earn money, and not because he was indifferent to what had happened

    but yes, i do agree to the last couple of lines. at the end of the day, its all about compulsion and how quickly is it necessary for you to get back to job and earn a living.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rebel--> I am not good at this( the writing on controversial subjects). But let me clear my stand, I am not bashing media for trudging up 'spirit', it's just that they have to start being more responsible and cover news for once ( One of the way they can do is by stopping to show 'comedy show' re runs and why Katrina is not speaking to Salman on primetime news).
    It's a fad to parade victims and ask them 'how are you feeling' type inane questions, instead they should shake the conscience of politicians and people to rise above petty issues and face the challenges.

    for your second point, it was the lower middle class videographer who was smiling and back to work ( he was not numb like the other guy). I am not passing sweeping judgments at all, just wondering if it was suppression of emotions or just a positive attitude. Or simply, the call for earning a living

    ReplyDelete
  3. Most of the cheap hindi news channels did a horrific job of covering the entire encounter.

    They foiled one or two police operations by leaking the details to the terrorists who had tuned in from inside the hotel premises.

    ReplyDelete